From childhood to lifelong care: Redefining congenital urology
Over the past decades, paediatric urology has achieved remarkable progress. Children born with complex congenital urological conditions now survive, undergo sophisticated reconstruction and reach adulthood with preserved renal function and continence. Whether they reach it with a good life is another question entirely: a flawless reconstruction in a patient who is continent but unhappy, or whose sexual life is poor, is not a good outcome. This success therefore creates a new responsibility. The challenge before us is no longer how to treat congenital conditions in childhood. It is how to provide lifelong care for the people born with them.

More than a surgical outcome
Our success has traditionally been measured anatomically: correction of the anomaly, preservation of renal function, continence, a sound reconstruction. These remain fundamental, but for a young person becoming an adult they are only part of the story. Does the patient understand their diagnosis and their operations? Can they manage their bladder independently? Our definition of success must evolve from "What did we achieve surgically?" to "What life have we enabled this patient to live?"
The gap opens before 18
Transition is a process, not a date - and the gap opens well before the birthday. Adolescents are often the least well served of all our patients: paediatric surgeons may feel poorly equipped for pubertal, sexual and fertility concerns, while adult urologists regard the patient as too young and too complex to take on, precisely when the young person's own questions become most pressing. Transfer moves a patient between clinics, and even that should never be done by letter alone: the paediatric surgeon and the adult urologist need to go through the history together, ideally with the patient there. Transition goes further, preparing a young person to lead their own care and the adult service to receive them, and it takes years. It should be gradual and documented, using a validated readiness scale rather than a clinical impression, and holistic: education, independence, psychological wellbeing and social circumstances alongside the medical plan. Above all, patients must learn their own history - what was done, when, why, and what it means for the future.
A shared responsibility
In 2019 a joint EAU-ESPU paper, written by paediatric and adult urologists together, set out the challenges of congenital lifelong urology (CLU) for both patients and surgeons [1]. Getting both groups around the same table was the right first step; seven years on, the conversation itself is no longer the achievement. Organising this cannot keep falling to paediatric urology by default. As outcomes improve, adult urologists increasingly meet patients whose history began in infancy, presenting with recurrent infection, incontinence, stones, channel or augmentation problems, sexual dysfunction, infertility or declining renal function, often with anatomy they have rarely encountered. Paediatric and adult urologists bring genuinely different visions of the same patient, and both are needed. The answer is not another isolated subspecialty, nor a handover at a fixed date, but responsibility held jointly, with neurourology, reconstructive and functional urology, reproductive medicine, nephrology, psychology and nursing alongside.
Think bottom up, not top down
Nowhere is that difference in vision clearer than in hydronephrosis. General urological training encourages a top-down approach: image the kidney, find the obstruction, relieve it. CLU thinks bottom up, from bladder to kidney. Combining cystometry with MAG3 renography, Hoh and colleagues showed that kidneys may fail to drain with a full bladder despite "normal" detrusor pressures, in several patients only above a threshold volume [2]; managing the bladder on that basis stabilises renal deterioration [3]. The dilated upper tract is the symptom; the bladder is the disease, and a stent or a pyeloplasty addresses neither.
Beyond the urinary tract
Lifelong care must also address continence, fertility and pregnancy, bowel function, independence and quality of life. Pregnancy deserves particular attention: women with complex lower urinary tract reconstruction can be delivered safely by a planned combined caesarean section with a urologist present, reducing the risk of injury to the reconstructed tract - which has to be anticipated years ahead. Sexual wellbeing deserves more than a line in a follow-up letter. Erectile and ejaculatory function, genital appearance, pain, continence during intimacy and the confidence to start a relationship are everyday concerns, rarely volunteered, that have to be asked about from adolescence onwards by someone comfortable doing so. We should also look beyond urological outcomes altogether. Young people with these conditions carry concerns about body image, acceptance, intimacy and confidence that no operative record captures, and we address them late, if at all. Psychological support belongs inside CLU services from childhood, and the psychological dimension of these conditions belongs in urological training.
A European opportunity
Transitional urology describes the bridge between childhood and adulthood. CLU describes the journey itself, and that change in language is a change in responsibility. The EAU is well placed to act: its Sections (ESPU, ESGURS and ESAU) hold complementary expertise, and the EAU Working Group on Paediatric Urology exists precisely to bring paediatric and adult urologists together. Our priorities should be education for adult urologists, structured transition pathways, registries that follow patients beyond childhood, and outcomes defined by patients.
For most of our patients the goal is not another technically successful operation. It is to study, work, form relationships, have children, live independently and stop thinking about their urinary tract every day. We should stop asking when congenital urology ends and start asking how we make it lifelong.
References
1. Wood D, Baird A, Carmignani L, De Win G, Hoebeke P, Holmdahl G, Manzoni G, Nijman RJM, Taylor C, Tekgul S. Lifelong congenital urology: the challenges for patients & surgeons. Eur Urol 2019;75(6):1001-7.
2. Hoh IM, Bomanji JB, Nagabhushan N, Chu A, Ell PJ, Neild GH, Woodhouse CRJ. Effect of the abnormal bladder when full on upper tract drainage using a combined cystometrogram-99mTc-mercapto-acetyltriglycine renogram: a prospective study. BJU Int 2007;100(5):1131-6.
3. Hale JM, Wood DN, Hoh IMY, Neild GH, Bomanji JB, Chu A, Woodhouse CRJ. Stabilization of renal deterioration caused by bladder volume dependent obstruction. J Urol 2009;182(4 Suppl):1973-7.